Summary: Tsukushi is the new scholarship student at the elite Eitoku Academy. Everything is going well until she stands up for a fellow classmate who is being bullied by the F4, four privileged, spoiled rich boys who run the school. By standing up to them, she earns a "red slip" which marks her as a target for bullying by the elite few. Even fellow students ignore her for fear of attracting attention to themselves. Not one to be bullied, Tsukushi stand up for herself and begins to inspire others to do the same.
Citation:
Kamio, Y. (2003). Boys over flowers. Hana yori dango (Vol. 1). San Francisco, CA: Viz.
Impressions: As much as I loved parts of this manga, I found other parts a bit to over the top for a shojo manga. For example, the F4 pay a group of boys to rape Tsukushi. The attempt is foiled but this is a romance manga and considering I know how the series ends (she ends up with the leader of the F4), I found that problematic for a title that is rated T for teen. If it hadn't been for the incident, I would have really liked this manga. The artwork is engaging and the theme is timely.
Reviews:
It's spring in Japan. News reports on the nuclear disaster, and havoc
and destruction wrought by the earthquake and tsunami are intertwined
with progress reports on the wave of cherry blossoms sweeping across the
nation. In the mountains, wild vegetables are beginning to push through
the snow. Many of these weeds are
sansai: mountain vegetables
prized for their delicate flavor and sold in farmer's markets. On a
given weekend, you may see women and a few men carefully poring over the
warming earth, foraging for
fuki no to (coltsfoot),
warabi (ferns) and my favorite,
tsukushi (horsetail shoot).
Tsukushi
also happens to be the name of my very favorite Japanese heroine. She's
the main character of Yoko Kamio's wildly successful manga series,
Hana Yori Dango, which loosely translates to
Boys Over Flowers, a pun that refers to people's preference for
dango, or
sweet rice dumplings, over flowers during a cherry blossom viewing
picnic. Trust me, it makes more sense in Japanese than English. All the
same, you must read this series.
The story begins at Eitoku
Academy, where the students have a novel approach to bullying: Every few
weeks an unsuspecting student opens his locker, sees a flag hanging
inside and hyperventilates. It's a signal that the student will now be
subject to mandatory ostracism and torture, while the cliquey F4, scions
of Japan's wealthiest families, will sit back and watch. It's
Gossip Girl meets
Survivor. Into this fray steps young Tsukushi, a scholarship student.
In the summer of 2007, I spent a great deal of time absorbing
Hana Yori Dango.
Why? I too, attended an elite prep school in northern California with a
trenchant cliquey system of which teachers were sometimes a part. I
too, cowered from bullies and skipped lunch altogether to avoid having
to figure out where to sit, while I longed for acceptance and escape.
I'm an adult now, but my adolescent me still cheers for Tsukushi.
Because when Tsukushi's friend is bullied, she takes on Domyoji,
the leader of the F4. Naturally, she gets a red flag. Incensed, she
declares war on the clique, later marching up to Domyoji and kicking him
in the face in the cafeteria. He topples over in full view of his
minions and falls instantly in love. So begins a very complicated
romance.
By the early 90s when the series came out, the "bamboo
shoot" days of post war Japan, in which the country was forced to
forage to find something to eat, had ended. But money did not provide an
answer to the existential questions of the Japanese youth. Nationwide
bullying became so popular an incident as to become a regular feature on
the nightly news.
In 2010, Princess Aiko, the only daughter of
the Crowned Prince, made headlines when she refused to attend school
due to harassment. In
Hana Yori Dango, Kamio was making a
statement about the impact of wealth on the young. But in Tsukushi, she
was also appealing directly to what she knew had made Japan so great:
kindness toward others, a belief in justice and fairness, and the
ability to regenerate, as wild weeds always do.
"I am a tough, wild weed!" Tsukushi often reminds Doumyoji, herself and
us, when facing challenges that might otherwise seem impossible to
surmount. With this strength, often missing in depictions of Japanese
women in the west, Tsukushi takes on the bullies in her school and her
own inner fears, to emerge a picture of composed triumph.
Mockett, M. M. (2011, March 28). Head over
heels for 'Boys Over Flowers' Retrieved from
http://www.npr.org/2011/04/15/134563204/head-over-heels-for-boys-over-flowers
Library Use: I think it would be a good way to generate a conversation about bullying and problematic favorite characters. This manga is extremely popular with middle and high school teens so I think it would be a great way to talk to teens about sexual violence.